Navigating Parenthood: Babylist vs Amazon Registry Showdown

If you are going to become a parent soon, you must be wondering which one to choose from Babylist vs Amazon Registry for your baby essentials. You don’t have to gather every bit of baby gear before your little one arrives, but having some essentials on hand is a game-changer. That’s where baby registries shine – a wish list for families to support your growing family.

These thoughtful baby shower gifts show love and set your child up for happy playtime, peaceful sleep, secure travels, and comfortable feeding. Before you start putting together your baby registry, pick a store with a reliable register that also lets you save such as Babylist Discount Codes.

It might be a no-brainer for some, but it’s worth checking out different websites to find the perfect fit for your needs. Look into return policies, freebies, discounts, brand variety, and group gifting, along with the range of products they offer.

There are a ton of alternatives for baby registries, so we’ve concentrated on two of the major ones in this post: Amazon, the largest e-commerce site in the world, and Babylist, one of the biggest sites dedicated to baby registries.

Babylist vs Amazon Registry: Which One’s Better?

To make the most of your new parenthood journey, a guide to Babylist vs Amazon Registry is inevitable. You must be wondering which baby registry to choose as the days of becoming parents get closer. To make things easy for you, this guide will provide you with insights on which one to choose.

Take your time exploring our list of online baby registries – they’ve got something for everyone, be it features, baby essentials, dreamy nursery picks, budget-friendly options, or preferred brands. Plus, don’t forget to keep an eye out for those precious freebies!

What is a Babylist Registry?

Babylists give parents the freedom and control to create the perfect registry for their little ones. Enter the world of Babylist registry which is a universal registry, where you’re not confined to one store. Add items from anywhere, and throw in cash funds, services, or second-hand treasures.

Enjoy a 15% completion discount, a welcome box, and group gifting. It’s user-friendly and accessible via browser or app, and you can personalize it with curated lists and recommendations. 

Share it easily with guests through links, inserts, or a custom URL.

What is an Amazon Registry?

An Amazon registry is like your virtual wishlist, perfect for occasions like weddings, baby showers, or birthdays. You’re not limited to Amazon – add stuff from any website. Score perks like a completion discount, a welcome box, and group gifting. Easily manage and track it from your Amazon account, even send thank-you notes. 

It’s a hassle-free way to clue in your loved ones on the gifts you’d love.

Babylist vs Amazon Registry: What Makes Them Different?

Universal Registry

Enter the world of Babylist vs Amazon registry, both as universal registries where you can toss in items from any online store, Amazon included. Your Babylist registry isn’t limited to things – throw-in services, experiences, cash funds, or even second-hand treasures. 

Grabbing goodies is a breeze with the Babylist button on your browser or the handy Babylist app.

On the flip side, Amazon Registry also plays the universal game, allowing you to stash items from any website, not just Amazon. Grab stuff from everywhere using the Amazon Assistant browser extension or the nifty Amazon app for your registry. It’s all about making your registry worth it.

Personalization Options

Take advantage of the Babylist app or website to scan barcodes, explore curated lists, or receive personalized suggestions. Easily track purchases and send heartfelt thank-you notes straight from your registry dashboard. Easily share your Babylist registry with guests via links, inserts, or custom URLs, spreading the excitement effortlessly.

The same goes for the Amazon registry which has an enormous selection of infant products, ranging from well-known brands to rare and niche products.

Amazon registry also has a user-friendly interface that lets you add items easily and navigate through them to add or remove your choices.

Gift Options

When we are talking about the Babylist vs Amazon Registry, how can we overlook the ‘gift options’ factor? Parents can use Babylist to receive contributions for big-ticket expenses like saving for their child’s future or buying items themselves.

They can use a debit or credit card to make their payments, and Babylist takes care of depositing the funds directly into your PayPal account.

On the other hand, while Amazon doesn’t do cash gifts, you can still spread the joy with an Amazon gift card. If you’re eager to donate money, you’ll need to explore other avenues for making a difference.

Free Gifts

If you’re up for it, you can get the Hello Baby Box, a bundle of goodies, from Babylist. It’s packed with stuff like swaddle blankets, nursing pads, bottles, diaper samples, and baby wipes. Just toss at least three items into your Babylist registry cart, spend a minimum of $10, and pay $9.95 plus VAT for shipping to get your hands on the box.

When it comes to Amazon’s baby registry welcome box, you’re in for a treat! Packed with goodies valued at $30 to $35, all you have to do is tick off 60% of your checklist, be a Prime member, and spend a minimum of $10 from the registry to get this special box.

Completion Discount

Lastly, your Babylist vs Amazon registry guide must mention the completion discounts.

As you approach your baby’s due date, enjoy a 15% completion discount starting 60 days before the big day with Babylist. And here’s the best part, you can use this discount for up to six months after your child arrives.

Just keep in mind, that this discount is exclusive to the Babylist store and can be applied once. Sadly, it doesn’t cover items from other retailers, and there are a few exclusions like specific brands, shipping costs, handling charges, and gift cards.

If you are a Prime member, Amazon gives you a 10% to 15% discount on registry items. Also, get a completion discount if you get the rest within 60 days of the baby’s due date.


There is no one-size-fits-all approach for Babylist vs Amazon registry as both platforms have their own set of pros and cons. If we talk about personalization and user interface, Babylist wins the race however, Amazon takes the lead with a variety of items and discounts.

Explore SlashMyPrice for top coupons from major retailers. Get amazing deals on electronics, apparel, cosmetics, gardening supplies, and more.